“To those outside the church…”
From pages 150-152 of the book “Dear Church”, by Sarah Cunningham… and from me:
To those outside the church, I am sorry for the times we under assessed your intelligence by assuming a few “cool” service elements, rather than real relationships, would draw you into our churches.
I am sorry for the times we presented Christianity as a three-step plan that you read and signed as if it were some type of credit application. That we sometimes acted as though Christianity and Christ were so simple and tidy that we could neatly package them inside a little box that you should be able to open and transplant into your spirit without any questions or hesitation. I am sorry that we sometimes brokered fire insurance — get-out-of-hell-free cards — instead of inviting you into God’s fullness. I’m sorry that we sometimes forgot to exemplify “kingdom” in this world… never mind the next.
I am sorry if we approached you or didn’t approach you based on external criteria like your socioeconomic class, skin color, education level, or any other trait that made you more or less like us. I am sorry for the times our message has isolated you, made you feel more judged than forgiven, or offended your family, friends, or people group in a way that was not biblical.
I am sorry for the times that we acted like your mistakes were worse than or own. I am sorry that we failed to realize that life is hard, just generally hard no mater who you are, and that we weren’t generous enough with grace and compassion unless it worked to our benefit.
I am sorry that we locked our doors when we drove through your neighborhoods or shirked you when you tried to talk to us in the checkout lines. that we spent more time avoiding you than really getting to know you, that we wrote you off before we even knew your names or stories. That we pretended to understand where you came from, when really we had never bothered to truly listen.
I am sorry when we acted like faith and doubt could never coexist, like it was wrong for you to have questions about why God allowed evil in the world, instead of encouraging you to ask the questions and grow through them. I am sorry when we acted like there were answers to every question when there are some questions we just can’t be sure about, that only God knows the answers to.
I am sorry that we sometimes told you what to believe, and how to believe, instead of letting you really discover and own your journey for yourselves.
I am sorry the we sometimes cared more about whether you came to our church or our choir concert or our youth group or our Bible school than we cared about whether you knew how to live in God’s fullness.
After all you may have been through, I understand if you have given up on the people within the local churches, but please don’t give up on our God. In the times we have made him out to be less than he was, cheapened his church by shaping it via our agenda instead of his, we have committed terrible offenses. Forgive us or don’t , but know that in our smartest and most sensible moments we would forget our pride or our desire to be the “most spiritual” and we would get down on our knees and beg you to reconsider the Savior who is eternally more noble and just than we are.
You must know that even if you can never respect the church, even if you doubt everything that comes out of our mouths, one thing that is still true is that Christ wants a relationship with you and that opening yourself up to him would be hands-down the best investment you could ever make in your life.
And if you come to follow Christ, I pray that you follow better and more closely than the rest of us have.
Most of all, I am sorry we haven’t apologized more often or sooner.